California Cities Call on Amazon to Fix ‘Tremendous Inequity’ in Tax Revenue

Todd Bishop, GeekWire
Todd Bishop is GeekWire's co-founder and editor, a longtime technology journalist who covers subjects including cloud tech, e-commerce, virtual reality, devices, apps and tech giants such as, Apple, Microsoft and Google. Follow him @toddbishop, email, or call (206) 294-6255.
California Cities Call on Amazon to Fix ‘Tremendous Inequity’ in Tax Revenue

Some California cities are calling on the state to return to a more equitable method of sharing tax revenue generated by Amazon's online sales — warning that a change made earlier this year creates an unfair system of "winners and losers" in the disbursement of millions of dollars used for critical public services.

The stakes are high: Amazon is bigger in California than in any other state, with 60 fulfillment and sortation centers, 50 delivery stations, and 153,000 employees. That's according to its official count as of the end of 2020. The numbers are even higher now, given the rapid expansion of Amazon's fulfillment and delivery network.

In theory, California's cities should be benefitting from that growth. Amazon has been collecting sales tax from online purchases in California since 2012.

Until this year, that tax revenue was disbursed based on the customer's location, going to the local municipality where the product was delivered. But as of earlier this year, the practice changed to give the tax revenue to the municipality from which the item was shipped, the location of the Amazon fulfillment center.

City officials from across the state will consider the issue at the upcoming League of California Cities annual conference. A proposal submitted to the group by the City of Rancho Cucamonga, Calif., would call on the state to enact "a fair and equitable distribution" of the 1% percent sales tax from in-state online purchases.

"This change has created a situation where most cities in California – more than 90%, in fact – are experiencing a sales tax revenue loss that began in the fourth quarter of calendar year 2021," reads a report from Rancho Cucamonga accompanying its proposal to the group, known as Cal Cities.

The report adds, "Many cities may not be aware of this impact, as the fluctuations in sales tax following the pandemic shutdowns have masked the issue. But this change will have long-term impacts on revenues for all California cities as all these revenues benefiting all cities have shifted to just a handful of cities and counties that are home to this retailer's fulfillment centers."

The change has resulted in Amazon's sales tax revenue "being entirely allocated to the specific city where the warehouse fulfillment center is located as opposed to going into a countywide pool that is shared with all jurisdictions," according to Rancho Cucamonga's proposal.

The proposal attributes the shift to a change by Amazon in the ownership of its fulfillment centers from a third-party vendor to the company itself, which alters how its sales are treated under California's tax policy.

Amazon disputes this explanation, and says it is simply following guidance from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), which determines how sales tax revenue for Amazon online purchases should be treated.

"As a company with operations in California, we are obligated to follow the tax collecting guidance set by the state and have adjusted our tax collection process to ensure we remain compliant with the law," an Amazon spokesperson said in a statement to GeekWire this week. "We are committed to investing in the communities in which we operate and helping local economies grow."

California cities rely heavily on sales tax as a revenue source, due the limitations put on property taxes by Proposition 13 starting in 1978. A 1% local sales tax, known as the Bradley Burns tax, has been in place across the state since the 1950s.

The change in tax revenue distribution from Amazon sales "has created a tremendous inequity amongst cities, in particular for cities that are built out, do not have space for siting a 1 million square foot fulfillment center, are not located along a major travel corridor, or otherwise not ideally suited to host a fulfillment center," the Rancho Cucamonga proposal says.

It adds, "These policies especially favor retailers who may leverage current policy in order to negotiate favorable sales tax sharing agreements, providing more money back to the retailer at the expense of funding critical public services."

The proposal acknowledges "that those cities that have fulfillment centers experience impacts from these activities and deserve equitable supplementary compensation." However, it adds, "the neighboring cities whose residents are ordering product from that center now receive no revenue from the center's sales activity despite also experiencing the impacts created by the center, such as increased traffic and air pollution."

Rancho Cucamonga's proposal received initial endorsements from cities including Placentia, Sacramento, Moorpark, Lakewood, La Verne, and El Cerrito. Leaders in other cities across the state have since signaled their support, as well.

The proposal will be considered at the Cal Cities annual conference, Sept. 22-24 in Sacramento. Approval would enable the group to pursue legislative changes.

This story originally appeared on GeekWire.

Subscribe to our newsletter to catch every headline.


A New Tide of LA Startups Is Tackling the National Childcare Crisis

Keerthi Vedantam

Keerthi Vedantam is a bioscience reporter at dot.LA. She cut her teeth covering everything from cloud computing to 5G in San Francisco and Seattle. Before she covered tech, Keerthi reported on tribal lands and congressional policy in Washington, D.C. Connect with her on Twitter, Clubhouse (@keerthivedantam) or Signal at 408-470-0776.

A New Tide of LA Startups Is Tackling the National Childcare Crisis
Courtesy of Brella

The pandemic exacerbated a problem that has been long bubbling in the U.S.: the childcare crisis.

According to a survey of people in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) careers conducted by the city’s WiSTEM Los Angeles program and shared exclusively with dot.LA, the pandemic exposed a slew of challenges across STEM fields. The survey—which consisted of 181 respondents from L.A.County and was conducted between March 2021 and 2022— involved respondents across medical fields, technical professions and science industries who shared the pandemic’s effects on their professional or education careers.

Read moreShow less

MaC Venture Capital Raises $203M for Its Second Fund

Decerry Donato

Decerry Donato is dot.LA's Editorial Fellow. Prior to that, she was an editorial intern at the company. Decerry received her bachelor's degree in literary journalism from the University of California, Irvine. She continues to write stories to inform the community about issues or events that take place in the L.A. area. On the weekends, she can be found hiking in the Angeles National forest or sifting through racks at your local thrift store.

MaC Venture Capital Raises $203M for Its Second Fund
Courtesy of MaC Venture Capital

While venture capital funding has taken a hit this year, that hasn’t stopped MaC Venture Capital from raising $203 million for its second fund.

The Los Angeles-based, Black-led VC firm said Monday that it had surpassed its initial $200 million goal for the fund, which dot.LA reported in January, over the span of seven months. MaC said it expects to invest the capital in up to 50 mostly seed-stage startups while remaining “sector-agnostic.”

Read moreShow less