Why Neobanks Are Having Such a Difficult Time Making Money

Samson Amore

Samson Amore is a reporter for dot.LA. He holds a degree in journalism from Emerson College. Send tips or pitches to samsonamore@dot.la and find him on Twitter @Samsonamore.

Why Neobanks Are Having Such a Difficult Time Making Money
Courtesy of Dave

Santa Monica-based financial technology company Dave is cutting its net losses, but the newly-public company has a ways to go before it’s profitable – a struggle that many “neobanks,” are facing.


In its recent first quarter earnings, Dave reported revenue of $58.9 million, against a net loss of $14 million. Though Dave has been steadily cutting its net loss over the last year in consecutive quarters, it’s still not profitable.

Dave’s core feature is ExtraCash, a program that allows users to receive up to $500 of their upcoming paycheck in advance, in exchange for a monthly $1 membership fee. Dave makes income from some other fees, like an additional $5.99 for advances over $100, and a $1.99 fee for express cash delivery.

These interest-free short-term loans led the app to surpass 1 million Dave Banking customers in 2020. In total, Dave now has 8.7 million members, the company said. American households are under increasing financial pressure, and that’s leading to an uptick in people looking for neobank services like fee-free banking and paycheck advances.

And people are increasingly relying on Dave’s advances to get by. In its first quarter earnings Dave reported its quarterly count of members increased 34% to 2 million, and the number of transactions those members made went up 19% compared to the same time a year prior. Some reviewers have noted they find the app helpful in times of emergency, or when they need a lift after a tough bill paying cycle.

“Dave was profitable in 2018 and 2019 and we’re confident we’ll get there again in 2024,” CEO Jason Wilk told dot.LA. “We made a deliberate investment in headcount over the last few years to grow our technology teams, and we know that was the right strategic decision for Dave.”

Neobanks directly capitalize off the unbanked (people who’ve never had a checking or savings account before), which is millions of Americans, especially people of color: According to the FDIC, roughly 5.9 million households were unbanked in 2021. The main reasons unbanked people gave for not having accounts were because they didn’t meet minimum balance requirements, and also, they just don’t trust banks.

“The consumers Dave serves are already struggling with a lack of credit and affordable banking options; they need a modern banking solution that works hard for them and addresses their specific needs,” Wilk said.

But while there are plenty of startups like Dave disrupting the financial sector, and there’s a clear need for the services and transparency they provide, the vast majority of neobanks are having a hard time making money: The same report found that less than 5% of these banks were breaking even.

“Even after adjusting for the high acquisition costs, the large majority of Neobanks still haven’t found the key to making money,” Simon Kucher & Partners’ Christoph Stegmeier and Matthias Verburg wrote in the report.

Private neobanks or digital payday lending services like Earnin or Brigit should be laser-focused on becoming sustainable even if investors pull back funding, according to David Stolpe, managing director of Wells Fargo’s Southern California Tech Banking division. Across the board, a decline in deal flow and exits so far this year has led to VCs being more cautious about deploying cash to startups in need of growth funding, and the fintech industry is no exception.

Another hindrance to any neobank’s growth is regulations, Stolpe said. He thinks neobanks are struggling a bit because “they need to lean on established rails within a highly-regulated industry, for them to be as effective as they can possibly be. It's really hard for a company like Dave or others in that space to be a fully functional replacement for a bank.”

Plenty of neobanks forge partnerships with smaller regional banks to hold deposits and provide features they cannot, Stolpe said, noting many debit card services offered by neobanks “are essentially a white-label off of another bank’s program.” In Dave’s case, its deposits are held by Tennessee-based Evolve Bank & Trust, which also issues the Dave debit cards.

But Stolpe added that companies like Dave and others are “not going to be a full bank until they have the capabilities to actually provide all those banking services that other chartered and regulated institutions can provide… that’s something that those [neobanks] have to build out.”

In particular, Stegmeier and Verburg recommended these fintech startups embrace buy now, pay later financing tools like those offered by Klarna or Sezzle, since it’s a form of credit that’s hot right now. They also encouraged neobanks to offer more options for financing real estate, or offer investing tools including automated portfolio management, like SoFi and Acorns do.

Stolpe noted that these neobanks like Dave “have to figure out the right way to charge for their product, whether it's interest on loans, or how much interest you're paying on deposits, or what their subscription on a monthly basis is… they've got to figure out a way to make that model work from a profitability perspective.”

Editor's Note: This story has been updated with comment from Dave CEO Jason Wilk.

https://twitter.com/samsonamore
samsonamore@dot.la
LA’s Upgrade in Travel and NBA Viewing
Image Source: Los Angeles World Airports

🔦 Spotlight

Exciting developments are underway for Los Angeles as the city prepares for major upgrades in both travel and entertainment. The Los Angeles Board of Airport Commissioners has approved an additional $400 million for the Automated People Mover (APM) at LAX, increasing its total budget to $3.34 billion. This boost ensures the elevated train’s completion by December 8, 2025, with service starting in January 2026. For Angelenos, this means a significant improvement in travel convenience. The APM will streamline connections between parking, rental car facilities, and the new Metro transit station, drastically cutting traffic congestion around the airport. Imagine a future without the dreaded 30-minute traffic delays at LAX! The APM will operate 24/7, reducing airport traffic by 42 million vehicle miles annually and carrying 30 million passengers each year, while also creating thousands of local jobs and supporting small businesses.

Meanwhile, the NBA is also making waves with its new broadcasting deals. The league has signed multi-year agreements with ESPN, NBC, and Amazon Prime Video, marking a notable shift in media partnerships. ESPN will maintain its long-standing role, NBC returns as a network broadcaster after years away, and Amazon Prime Video will provide NBA games through its streaming platform. Starting with the 2025-2026 season, these deals will enhance the league's reach and revenue, aligning with the NBA's goal to expand its audience and adapt to evolving viewing habits. Whether you're catching the action on TV or streaming online, these changes promise to elevate the fan experience and bring more basketball excitement to Los Angeles.


🤝 Venture Deals

LA Companies

  • Pearl, a startup that makes AI-powered software that assists dentists in identifying cavities, gum disease, and other dental conditions, raised a $58M Series B funding led by Left Lane Capital with Smash Capital, and others also participating. - learn more

LA Venture Funds

  • Fulcrum Venture Group participated in a prior $3.5M Pre-Seed Round for Code Metal, a developer tools startup. - learn more
  • B Capital co-led a $12.5M Seed Round for Star Catcher, a startup that aims to develop a space-based grid that captures solar energy in space and distributes it to satellites and other space assets. - learn more
  • Mantis VC and Amplify participated in a $140M Series C for Chainguard, an open source security startup. - learn more
  • Prominent LA venture capitalist, Carter Reum and wife, Paris Hilton, participated in a $14M Seed/Series A for W, the men’s personal care brand from Jake Paul. - learn more

LA Exits


Download the dot.LA App

🤫 The Secret to Staying Fit at Your Desk: 6 Essential Under-Desk Exercise Machines

Health experts are sounding the alarm: our sedentary jobs are slowly killing us, yet we can't abandon our desks if we want to keep the lights on. It feels like we're caught between a rock and a hard place. Enter under-desk exercise machines – the overlooked heroes (albeit kind of goofy looking) of the modern workspace. These devices let tech professionals stay active, enhance their health, and increase their productivity, all without stepping away from their screens. Here are 6 fantastic options that will enhance the way you work and workout simultaneously.

DeskCycle Under Desk Bike Pedal Exerciser

This bike has nearly ten thousand five-star reviews on amazon. It works with nearly any desk/chair setup. It is quiet, sturdy and allows up to 40 pounds of resistance. If you are looking for an under-desk bike this is a fantastic option.

Type: Under-Desk Bike

Price: $180 - $200


Sunny Health & Fitness Dual Function Under Desk Pedal Exerciser

This under-desk bike is extremely quiet due to the magnetic resistance making it an ideal option if you work in a shared space. It doesn’t slip, has eight levels of resistance, and the option to work legs and arms. It’s about half the price of the DeskCycle bike making it a solid mid-range option for those looking to increase their daily activity.

Type: Under-Desk Bike

Price: $100 - $110


Sunny Health & Fitness Sitting Under Desk Elliptical

This under-desk elliptical comes in multiple colors if you really want to underscore that you are a quirky individual, in case an under-desk elliptical isn’t enough. This model is a bit heavy (very sturdy), has eight different resistance levels, and has more than nine thousand 5-star reviews.

Type: Under-Desk Elliptical

Price: $120 - $230


DeskCycle Ellipse Leg Exerciser

This under-desk elliptical is another great option. It is a bit pricey but it’s quiet, well-made and has eight resistance levels. It also syncs with your apple watch or fitbit which is a very large perk for those office-wide “step” challenges. Get ready to win.

Type: Under-Desk Elliptical

Price: $220 - $230


Daeyegim Quiet LED Remote Treadmill

If you have a standing desk and are looking to walk and work this is a fantastic option. This walking-only treadmill allows you to walk between 0.5 to 5 mph (or jog unless you have the stride length of an NBA forward). It is very quiet, which is perfect if you want to use it near others or during a meeting. You can’t change the incline or fold it in half but it is great for simply getting in some extra steps during the work day.

Type: Under-Desk Treadmill

Price: $220 - $230


Sunny Health & Fitness Foldable Manual Treadmill

This under-desk treadmill isn’t the most premium model but it is affordable and has an impressive array of features. It is a manual treadmill meaning it doesn’t need to be plugged in; it is foldable and offers an incline up to 13%. I personally can’t imagine working and walking up a 13% incline but if that sounds like your cup of tea, then I truly respect the hustle.

Type: Under-Desk Treadmill

Price: $150 - $200




Download the dot.LA App

🤠Musk Picks Texas and 🔥Tinder AI Picks Your Profile Pictures

🔦 Spotlight

Tinder is altering dating profile creation with its new AI-powered Photo Selector feature, designed to help users choose their most appealing dating profile pictures. This innovative tool employs facial recognition technology to curate a set of up to 10 photos from the user's device, streamlining the often time-consuming process of profile setup. To use the feature, users simply take a selfie within the Tinder app and grant access to their camera roll. The AI then analyzes the photos based on factors like lighting and composition, drawing from Tinder's research on what makes an effective profile picture.

The selection process occurs entirely on the user's device, ensuring privacy and data security. Tinder doesn't collect or store any biometric data or photos beyond those chosen for the profile, and the facial recognition data is deleted once the user exits the feature. This new tool addresses a common pain point for users, as Tinder's research shows that young singles typically spend about 25 to 33 minutes selecting a profile picture. By automating this process, Tinder aims to reduce profile creation time and allow users to focus more on making meaningful connections.

In wholly unrelated news, Elon Musk has announced plans to relocate the headquarters of X (formerly Twitter) and SpaceX from California to Texas. SpaceX will move from Hawthorne to Starbase, while X will shift from San Francisco to Austin. Musk cited concerns about aggressive drug users near X's current headquarters and a new California law regarding gender identity notification in schools as reasons for the move. This decision follows Musk's previous relocation of Tesla's headquarters to Texas in 2021.

🤝 Venture Deals

LA Companies

LA Venture Funds

LA Exits

  • Penguin Random House agreed to acquire comic book publisher Boom! Studios from backers like Walt Disney Co. - learn more

Download the dot.LA App

RELATEDEDITOR'S PICKS
Trending